From Bob Stone

Statements

Straight talk on the issues that matter to Huntsville — reducing taxes and managing our growth.

01
Reducing Taxes

Coming out of COVID, prices for goods and services across the planet soared and the Town was not immune, resulting in one year with a very high increase. That increase however was mitigated when combined with a low District levy. Despite that very bad year, property taxes have risen 20.8% over the past four years.

In the past, Council and staff were not willing to look at reducing the services we provide in order to reduce the tax levy. I believe that we are at a crossroads in a very difficult economy and we cannot continue as we have.

I will propose in the next budget deliberations that each department bring back to Council a plan outlining how they would cut their costs and/or services to reduce their budget by 5%. I believe this exercise will reveal not only operational opportunities, but will result in a very low or zero increase in the coming years.

02
Huntsville is Changing

I would like to address the many comments on Huntsville Doppler and social media about Planning Council, Housing and the Growth of Huntsville.

The unprecedented influx of people to Huntsville began with the Covid Pandemic and continues today. Huntsville is changing and that is inevitable, but there are some things we can do to mitigate the effects.

To paraphrase some comments on social media, people have said:

"Why don't you just stop approving the large developments that are drastically changing the Huntsville we love."

"Why allow all the exceptions instead of sticking to the by-laws and the Official Plan."

"It's too big for the neighbourhood, don't allow it."

"All the units should be affordable."

"No more fast-food restaurants"

Let me begin by making a few points:

The development on Forbes Hill (behind Muskoka Heritage Place) that clearcut the top of the hill, the building on Brunel Rd. that sits between the river and the sidewalk and the Condos on Hwy 60 that are built too close to the water all received their planning approval many years ago and would NOT be allowed today. The reason they are being built now is because it is finally profitable to do so.

The Provincial Government dictates the planning rules that we MUST follow through the Provincial Policy Statement (PPS). They have recently been changing those rules to make it easier for developers to build more homes, but not always as we would like. We also have our own planning rules through our Official Plan to encourage development while protecting what we love about Huntsville.

The main reason Huntsville Planning Council exists is to adjudicate planning applications that fall outside of the existing rules. Anyone who owns property can use their property as they wish provided it fits within our bylaws. If it doesn't fit, then they can ask Council for an exception. We do not have the power to say no more building or no more businesses.

In my opinion there is NOT a housing crisis, there is only a rental housing crisis. If you have a million dollars burning a hole in your pocket, you can buy a home today. Not so for the young people trying to start their lives on their own. The average income has not kept up with the wild raise in the cost of everything from homes to groceries and the gap keeps widening. Many young people today have realised that they may never own their own home like the generations before them. The cost to rent an apartment is often a stretch even if they can find one to rent. If we can increase the supply of rental units, the marketplace will bring that cost down. In order to increase the supply, we need to allow developers to build and if it is not profitable for them, they will not build. So where is the middle ground between big enough to be profitable and not too big as to be a blight on the landscape?

Over the past two years our staff have been working on a Height and Density Study that has now been completed and approved by Council. This document lays out exactly where it may be appropriate to allow taller buildings (4 - 6 stories) and where development and taller buildings should never be allowed. It also identifies the tops of hills and vistas that must be protected from development to maintain what we love about Huntsville.

When a developer doesn't agree with a decision of Planning Council they have the right to go to the Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT) to get a ruling. When this happens, the Town can participate with its own Lawyers and Planners. This is extremely expensive for the Town and in recent years the OLT has almost always sided with the developer whenever housing is concerned. This is one reason that Town staff and Council try to find a compromise on developments to mitigate the impacts before they go to the OLT and probably get everything they want.

As much as we love the ideal of the "1980's Huntsville", we are inevitably changing. We can't prevent people from coming and we can't stop developers from building on their property. We do have the ability to mold that change through good planning practices and protecting those things that we love about this place we call home.

Other items of note;

The Empire lot on the corner of Main St. and Centre St. downtown is privately owned and the Town cannot do anything with it, however, we have been working with the owner and hope they will bring a plan forward soon.

Short Term Rentals (STR's) have taken rental units off the market, but Town Council has implemented a licensing system and has limited the number of STR's allowed to 250.

The District will be hiring approximately 130 more people to work at the new Fairvern and they will all need housing.

Council commissioned a Housing Needs Assessment in 2024 which resulted in a Housing Action Plan with 16 initiatives to increase the supply of rental units (15 have already implemented). The town has also released 6 designs of pre-approved building permit drawings for anyone wishing to build an accessory dwelling on their property.

The Town and District have been working with The Muskoka Community Land Trust to bring 176 rental units to the Town owned property on Florance St. W.

40 Rental units are under construction at the corner of Taite and Main St W.

Council has also approved 100 rental units beside the new Festing Toyota.

The District is increasing the capacity for waste water at the Golden Pheasant Treatment Plant on Hwy 60 and upgrading infrastructure for water and waste water so there is capacity for growth long into the future.

← Back to Home